Sycophancy in GPT-4o

OpenAI found itself in the middle of another controversy earlier this week, only this time it wasn’t about publishers or regulation, but about its core product – ChatGPT. Specifically, after rolling out an update to the default 4o model with improved personality, users started noticing that ChatGPT was adopting highly sycophantic behavior: it weirdly agreed with users on all kinds of prompts, even about topics that would typically warrant some justified pushback from a digital assistant. (Simon Willison and Ethan Mollick have a good roundup of the examples as well as the change in the system prompt that may have caused this.) OpenAI had to roll back the update and explain what happened on the company’s blog:

We have rolled back last week’s GPT‑4o update in ChatGPT so people are now using an earlier version with more balanced behavior. The update we removed was overly flattering or agreeable—often described as sycophantic.

We are actively testing new fixes to address the issue. We’re revising how we collect and incorporate feedback to heavily weight long-term user satisfaction and we’re introducing more personalization features, giving users greater control over how ChatGPT behaves.

And:

We also believe users should have more control over how ChatGPT behaves and, to the extent that it is safe and feasible, make adjustments if they don’t agree with the default behavior.

Today, users can give the model specific instructions to shape its behavior with features like custom instructions. We’re also building new, easier ways for users to do this. For example, users will be able to give real-time feedback to directly influence their interactions and choose from multiple default personalities.

“Easier ways” for users to adjust ChatGPT’s behavior sound to me like a user-friendly toggle or slider to adjust ChatGPT’s personality (Grok has something similar, albeit unhinged), which I think would be a reasonable addition to the product. I’ve long argued that Siri should come with an adjustable personality similar to CARROT Weather, which lets you tweak whether you want the app to be “evil” or “professional” with a slider. I increasingly feel like that sort of option would make a lot of sense for modern LLMs, too.

→ Source: openai.com